Wednesday, March 29, 2017

Electoral College vs Popular Vote

This idea of election by popular vote was rejected not because the framers distrusted the people but rather because the larger populous States would have much greater influence than the smaller States and therefore the interests of those smaller States could be disregarded or trampled. Additionally, a nationwide election would encourage regionalism since the more populous areas of the country could form coalitions to elect president after president from their own region. With such regional preferentialism, lasting national unity would be nearly impossible.
Why Was The Electoral College Method Chosen?
The Electoral College synthesized two important philosophies established in the Constitution: (1) the maintenance of a republican, as opposed to a democratic, form of government and (2) the balancing of power between the smaller and the larger States and between the various diverse regions of the nation
When establishing our federal government, smaller States like Rhode Island had feared they would have no voice, and therefore no protection, against the more populous States like New York or Massachusetts. Similarly, the sparsely populated agricultural regions feared an inability to protect their interests against the fishing and shipping industries dominant in the more populous coastal States. These concerns on how to preserve individual State voices and diverse regional interests caused the framers to establish a bi-cameral rather than a uni-cameral legislative system.
In that wise plan, one body preserved the will of the majority as determined by population and the other preserved the will of the majority as determined by the States. As Constitution signer James Madison confirmed:
The Constitution is nicely balanced with the federative and popular principles; the Senate are the guardians of the former, and the House of Representatives of the latter; and any attempts to destroy this balance, under whatever specious names or pretenses they may be presented, should be watched with a jealous eye.
Consequently, in the Senate, Delaware has the same power as California with each State having two votes; but in the House, Delaware’s single vote often is completely negated by the fifty-two from California. Because of this different source of strength in each body, the votes in those two bodies on the same piece of legislation may be dramatically different. In such a case, before that legislation may become law there must be some compromise — some yielding of the Senate to the will of the population and some yielding of the House to the will of the States. As James Madison explained, the Electoral College wisely synthesized both of these important interests:
As to the eventual voting by States, it has my approbation. The lesser States and some larger States will be generally pleased by that mode. The deputies from the small States argued, and there is some force in their reasoning, that, when the people voted, the large States evidently had the advantage over the rest, and, without varying the mode, the interests of the little States might be neglected or sacrificed. Here is a compromise.
James Hillhouse (a soldier during the American Revolution and a U. S. Representative and Senator under Presidents George Washington, John Adams, Thomas Jefferson, and James Madison) also affirmed this principle, explaining:
The principle of the Constitution, of election by electors, is certainly preferable to all others. . . . [because] Pennsylvania, Virginia, Massachusetts, and New York, may combine; they may say to the other [smaller] States, we will not vote for your man. . . . [or] the agricultural will be arrayed against the mercantile; the South against the East; the seaboard against the inland.
Consequently, under the Electoral College system, the smaller States receive a slightly greater voice, proportionally speaking. For example, California is the largest State and its 33 million inhabitants have 54 electors, each of whom represents 614,000 inhabitants. However, Wyoming is the smallest State and its less than one-half million inhabitants are represented by only 3 electors — one for every 160,000 inhabitants. This therefore gives Wyoming slightly more proportional strength. As Uriah Tracy (a Major-General during the Revolution and a U. S. Representative and Senator under Presidents George Washington, John Adams, and Thomas Jefferson) observed during debates on the Electoral College:
He [the president] is to be chosen by electors appointed as the State legislatures shall direct, not according to numbers entirely, but adding two electors in each State as representatives of State sovereignty. Thus, Delaware obtains three votes for president, whereas she could have but one in right of numbers [population].
So, on the one hand, the electoral college tends somewhat to overrepresent voters in smaller States; and no matter how small a State is, it is guaranteed at least 3 electors because, as explained by James Bayard (a U. S. Representative and U. S. Senator under Presidents John Adams, Thomas Jefferson, and James Madison), the electoral college supplied a “means of self-protection” to “a small State without resources.”  In fact, the combined number of electors in the eight smallest States (Alaska, Delaware, North Dakota, South Dakota, Vermont, Wyoming, Montana, and Rhode Island) produce the same number of electors as the single State of Florida even though Florida has a population more than three times greater than those eight smaller States combined.
Yet, on the other hand, if a candidate wins California and its 54 electoral votes, then that candidate is one-fifth of the way to the 270 electoral votes needed to capture the presidency. Thus, while California accounts for only 11 percent of the nation’s population it can provide 20 percent of the electoral votes needed to obtain the presidency. The Electoral College system therefore preserves a sound balance between population centers and between diverse State and regional interests, incorporating elements both of popular and of State representation in its operation.
John Taylor (an officer during the American Revolution and a U. S. Senator under Presidents George Washington and Thomas Jefferson) observed:
Two principles sustain our Constitution: one a majority of the people, the other a majority of the States; the first was necessary to preserve the liberty or sovereignty of the people; the last, to preserve the liberty or sovereignty of the States. But both are founded in the principle of majority; and the effort of the Constitution is to preserve this principle in relation both to the people and the States, so that neither species of sovereignty or independence should be able to destroy the other.
James Madison agreed, affirming:
In our complex system of polity, the public will, as a source of authority, may be the will of the people as composing one nation, or the will of the States in their distinct and independent capacities; or the federal will as viewed, for example, through the presidential electors, representing in a certain proportion both the nation and the States.
This blending of the will of the population and the will of the States is why it is possible — and has thrice occurred — that a President may win the popular vote but lose the electoral vote (on those previous occasions, the margin of victory in the popular vote was less than 1 percent). Usually, however, the Electoral College tends to exaggerate the margin of victory of the popular vote rather than run counter to it.
The Benefits of the Electoral College System
There are three important benefits produced by the current Electoral College system:
(1) Because a candidate must win at least 270 electoral votes from across the nation, a candidate cannot become president without a significant widespread voter base. In fact, as has happened in three previous elections, the distribution of voter support may actually take precedence over the quantity of voter support. Therefore, the Electoral College ensures a broad national consensus for a candidate that subsequently will allow him to govern once he takes office.
(2) Since the electoral college operates on a State-by-State basis, this not only enhances the status of minorities by affording them a greater proportional influence within a smaller block of voters at the State level but it also ensures a geographically diverse population which makes regional domination, or domination of urban over suburban or rural areas, virtually impossible. In fact, since no one region of the country has 270 electoral votes, there is an incentive for a candidate to form coalitions of States and regions rather than to accentuate regional differences.
(3) The Electoral College system prioritizes the most important factors in selecting a president. If a candidate receives a substantial majority of the popular vote, then that candidate is almost certain to receive enough electoral votes to be president. However, if the popular vote is extremely close, then the candidate with the best distribution of popular votes will be elected. And if the country is so divided that no one candidate obtains an absolute majority of electoral votes, then the U. S. House of Representatives — the body closest to the people and which must face them in every election — will then choose the president.
NOTE: There are many groups, such as that hare-brained bunch of mindless nymphs called the League of Women Voters who want the Electoral College abolished in favor of the Popular Vote. In addition, there are mindless blowhard individuals who bloviate on that which his/ her tiny mind is incapable of understanding.
The audacity of the groups and individuals is exceeded only by their arrogance. They actually compare their intellect, understanding and wisdom to that of our Founding Fathers. That comparison in itself is sufficient to have them declared certifiably insane.

Read and try to understand the above and then tell me you would like to join the League of Women Voters. I will provide them with a letter of recommendation for you, along with a nice little calico smock for your induction.

Commerce Clause

Commerce Clause
Article 1 Section 8 Clause 3
“To regulate commerce with foreign nations, and among the several states, and with the Indian tribes;”
“And” is the key word here because it tells us the power to regulate foreign commerce is the exact same as the power to regulate interstate commerce. That’s critical because it means that any type of commerce that Congress can regulate domestically among the states also has to be something it could regulate with a foreign country.
What’s cool about that is it makes it very easy for you to figure out what Congress has the authority to regulate when it comes to commerce “among the several states.”
For Congress to have the power to regulate something in interstate commerce, that regulation would have to make sense in this sentence:
“Congress has the power to regulate ______________ with foreign nations.”
Anything that doesn’t fit logically into that sentence would be unconstitutional for Congress to regulate under the Commerce Clause. United States v. Lopez (1995)
Try this one for instance, with respect to the Affordable Care Act aka ObamaCare:
Congress has the power to regulate healthcare with foreign nations.
Ya think?
How about with respect to the Minimum Wage:
“Congress has the power to regulate minimum wages with foreign nations.”
Once again, it just ain’t workin’ for me.
Minimum Wage
It’s funny because I have seen that Congress has voted against an increase in the Minimum Wage 15 times in the past 2 years. I had to go look again at Article 1, Section 8 to see if I could find where we had passed a Constitutional Amendment on the matter whilst I slept… We had not. So, I read again Article 1, Section 8, the express powers of Congress. Could not find one clause where Minimum Wage would fall under those powers. So I remembered to look at the Commerce Clause again, the Clause Liberal adherents to Constitutional Case Law love to throw everything into so FED GOV can usurp the States and the People.
How about following the same sense of the Commerce Clause with respect to the Minimum Wage:
“Congress has the power to regulate minimum wages with foreign nations.”
Once again, it just ain’t workin’ for me.
My personal favorite though is utilizing the Commerce Clause to determine Congressional jurisdiction over transgender bathrooms. Here we go again…
How about with respect to the Transgender Bathrooms:
“Congress has the power to regulate where to pee with foreign nations.”
That one just fell flat with me, kinda’ like a snake run over by a steam roller.
I know that some of you Alice in Wonderland liberals just hate that all of the above are not in Article 1, Section 8. Truth be known, there are some women most of us men would love to follow anywhere, including the Ladies Bathroom. Add to that the assertion that nothing is forever, including the US Constitution. They would be correct. The Founding Fathers, keeping that in mind, provided 2 methods to amend the Constitution. So, go ahead, amend it so we can all pee pee together; after all, the family that pee pees together, sticks together. You cannot however, skirt the Constitution, as amended; just because it makes you wee wee in your diaper.

Wah wah wah wah wah…

General Welfare Clause

          “If Congress can apply money indefinitely to the general welfare, and are the sole and supreme judges of the general welfare, they may take the care of religion into their own hands; they may establish teachers in every State, county, and parish, and pay them out of the public Treasury; they may take into their own hands the education of children, establishing in like manner schools throughout the Union; they may undertake the regulation of all roads other than post roads.  In short, everything, from the highest object of State legislation, down to the most minute object of police, would be thrown under the power of Congress; for every object I have mentioned would admit the application of money, and might be called, if Congress pleased, provisions for the general welfare.” James Madison, 1792 Cod Fishing Debate.
          The first clause in Article 1 Section 8 is known as the General Welfare Clause. According to James Madison, the clause authorized Congress to spend money but only to carry out the powers as enumerated in the following clauses of Article 1, not to meet the seemingly endless needs of the general welfare. That is a power reserved to the States in the 10th Amendment.
          It seems that Madison was prescient; knowing a bunch of idiots would think they deserved a bunch of free stuff and a MORON that would give it to them.
Further discussion: 
          See Madison’s Notes on the Constitutional Convention: http://consource.org/document/james-madisons-notes-of-the-constitutional-convention-1787-9-17/
          These include the daily Notes from May 25, 1787 through September 17, in total. Also are Records of the Proceedings by the various delegates.
Summary of the balance of Sect 8:
Borrow money
Regulate Commerce
Establish a Rule of Naturalization
Establish a Uniform Rule on Bankruptcies
To Coin money & regulate the value
Fix the Standard of Weights and Measures
Provide the punishment for counterfeiting
Establish Post Offices and Post Roads
Provide for Copywriting
Establish Tribunals inferior to the Supreme Court
Define and punish piracies on the high seas
Declare War
Raise and support Armies for 2 year intervals
Provide and maintain a Navy
Make Rules for the Government and Regulation of the land and naval Forces
Provide for calling forth the Militia to execute the Laws of the Union, suppress Insurrections and repel Invasions
Provide for organizing, arming, and disciplining, the Militia
Exercise exclusive Legislation in all Cases whatsoever, over the District [of Columbia] and exercise authority over all federal military installations
Make all Laws necessary and proper for carrying into Execution the foregoing
Each of the foregoing would be categorized under the aegis of the 3 Powers:
Provide for the Common Defense
Insure Domestic Tranquility
Promote the General Welfare
As follows:
Provide for the Common Defense—
Establish Tribunals inferior to the Supreme Court
Define and punish piracies on the high seas
Declare War
Raise and support Armies for 2 year intervals
Provide and maintain a Navy
Make Rules for the Government and Regulation of the land and naval Forces
Insure Domestic Tranquility—
Provide for calling forth the Militia to execute the Laws of the Union, suppress Insurrections and repel Invasions
Provide for organizing, arming, and disciplining, the Militia
Exercise exclusive Legislation in all Cases whatsoever, over the District [of Columbia] and exercise authority over all federal military installations
Promote the General Welfare—
Borrow money
Regulate Commerce--See Commerce Clause
Establish a Rule of Naturalization
Establish a Uniform Rule on Bankruptcies
To Coin money & regulate the value
Fix the Standard of Weights and Measures
Provide the punishment for counterfeiting
Establish Post Offices and Post Roads
Provide for Copywriting
All else is reserved to the States and to the People

Transformation of Downtown Seminole

          There is a transformation of what was the Seminole of old, from Tidmore, Oklahoma Indian Territory, to one of the biggest Boom Towns in the history of these United States, Seminole, Oklahoma. Keep your eyes open and you will be filled with pride. Walk into Kalico Kitchen. That was once the entrance of Matthews Grocery, co-owned by Winford Fizer Matthews, Sr. and James Newton Harber. First Nat’l Bank was owned by Harber—his In-Law was my grandfather. The exit was at about the old Hammons Men’s Wear front, also life-long friends of grandpa. J.N. Harber bailed. Grandpa bought him out, both transplants from Izard Co., AR, parent County of Baxter County, of Grisso fame. Of the families that started this experiment, there were the families of Chase, Harber, Matthews, Seay, Noe, etc.  They began this town, along with the Matthews family, their In-Laws, all of which married the daughters and granddaughters of Robert Calvin Matthews, my G-G-Grandfather.
          An entity is preserving all of this. The Grisso, Worth, Pat’s CafĂ©, Corral Room, Hideaway Bar, along with my Grandfather’s second store, now Seminole Discount Store, has been renovated. Underway is the American Legion Hut, now being brought back to its original integrity. The gas station at “Crazy Corner” is underway, providing a Full Service gas station and relevant products. If you frequent these locations, you will be a part of our history. The Crazy Corner is one of the original borders of the original Seminole, now being bordered by “South of the Tracks”.
          The old American Legion Hut is no exception. It has been brought back to its original integrity. On Saturday was a birthday party. There will be another, this coming Saturday and the next. The 1967 50 year Reunion may have an event there this September.  Excitement is back if you will.
          If you go to Bumpy Brick, you will feel the original spirit of our predecessors. I promise that. Pat’s was a local haunt. The Worth Hotel had an altogether different market niche’. We danced in the basement of the Grisso at the Corral Room. The Hideaway Bar was unknown to almost all of us. If you venture there, you will sense the history, you will feel it. You will become a part of that history.

          The very beginning of the history is at hand. I knew all of these originals. Go shake their hands, spend time at their haunts, tell them thank you and especially thank those who are bringing you back to them—they will smile upon you. If you venture into Seminole Discount Liquor, envision my grandfather at the counter, butchering his own meats, a pickle barrel, a cracker barrel and local products from local farmers in audience. His smile would make you smile. I sure do miss him and I sure do miss that time in Seminole, the “Miracle City”.

Nailed by Foul Ball Whilst Skating

          I read a Facebook post this morning that spurred great concern for our little tykes and tots. A siren call for a net over our skate park or batter’s box was intimated to protect our little progenies, due to the fact that the little love monkeys are being pummeled by foul balls, administrated by evil ballplayers at bat. Who could possibly deny them this protection? I recall, as a tyke, in days of yore, that we would station ourselves behind the fence strategically so we could catch foul balls, bare-handed of course. Knuckle-draggers we were—dread the thought. This would be money well spent, assuming we could at least fill the crater on Strothers at David Boren Boulevard first.
          Who in their right mind would want to skate without a net!? I play tennis, with my Tennis Tutor of course, just across the street from said skate park. I think we should broaden the net to include the tennis courts, waterpark, etc. We could even be forward thinking sufficiently to include the old rodeo grounds, just in case we might attract a rodeo or maybe some giant retailer in the near future. Lest we forget our champion swimmers and golfers too! It would be really special if we made the net from Kevlar, which might also protect some innocent from a meteorite. What are the odds…
          I must admit, it would be a form of family embarrassment to have to post on the tombstone of your firstborn male child, “Here lies l’il Jeffrey, nailed by a foul ball whilst skating.” Dread the thought.

Just think, Seminole could become the global model for safe spaces interspersed in various places around town. Downtown, we need safe spaces surrounded by fireproof lining, in addition to the overhead nets, due to the mysterious spontaneous combustion events that appear out of nowhere from time to time. Who’s on first? OMG!!!

State and Local Funding for Education

I watched an interview this morning of Governor LePage, Maine. He was lamenting the fact that "only 59% of state educational funding gets to the student, 6 points less than the national average of 65%." Another group says it is about 60% on average, although each jurisdiction has a little bit different definition of actual per student funding. He also pointed out something remarkable: "while per-pupil spending has risen by about 27 percent over the past decade, the number of students in Maine schools has dropped by about 11 percent to less than 180,000." Sound familiar? It should to Oklahomans and especially Oklahomans in Seminole. Actually Governor LePage is doing quite well. In Oklahoma, only 56% of the money makes it to the classroom. Texas, on our southern border has theirs at 61%. The most egregious and glaring fact in Oklahoma is not that however. When I was in SPS, 66% of funding for SPS was local, less than one-third was state and federal funding was statistically insignificant. That has flip-flopped; local funding for SPS is about 30%. Those who lament the fact that we have lost local control forget that we gave up local control for education when we gave up funding "local" education, locally. BTW—the percentage decrease in the number of students at SHS was about the same as the State of Maine, 10%, give or take, over the same period. Problem defined; work on it.

Really?!


As we wander again, aimlessly, trying as we might to make certain that every US citizen has healthcare and health insurance, two very distinctly different subjects, we should be reminded again, why that is just not possible. When the framers were setting up this system of government, they chose very few federal prerogatives knowing that a central government cannot fix a one size fits all framework outside of that small list in Art 1 Section 8. It just cannot be done. It could not be accomplished even for 13 very distinctly different Colonies and it will never be done with 50 states and the District of Columbia. The Colony of New York and the Colony of Rhode Island were not even remotely alike, then or now. Today, the former Colonies, and now States, of Maryland and Virginia are so different they might as well be on different planets. I lived in Virginia for a quarter century and I KNOW this to be true.
          I have been to the remotest stretches of NW China and I have been to Mexico City. If you wander outside of the Zona Rosa in Mexico City, or visit that region of China, you too would remark that no one in the US of A lives in poverty. Period! That is a fact, not fake news.
          This problem exists in each and every form of government known to man. They have all tried to fix it and all have failed; socialism, communism, capitalism, democracy et al. If you try to design a fix by instituting a totalitarian regime, headed by a benevolent dictator, you will fail. Giving that kind of power to a “king” is destined to fail. The framers were well acquainted with such totalitarian regimes and they came up with our form of government to avoid that and avoid the possibility of that in our Constitution. Power corrupts but absolute power corrupts absolutely. Absolute power in the hands of a despot is merely a weapon.
          “But, you say, we all have a right to healthcare and even health insurance.” Or, “But some will not have healthcare or health insurance if we don’t fix it”. Where in God’s name did you come up with that nonsensical idea? Here is a concept for you. In the good ole USA, we are all born with an equal opportunity to succeed. Some do, some do not, no matter your form of centralized government. In every system of government, the cream rises to the top and the failed sleep in a shanty, or under a bridge.
          Guess what, we do not all have a car—5% of the driving age population do not have a car. Many of those cannot even afford a bus ticket. Go figure. Guess what else; 14% of those who do have an automobile do not have auto insurance. The vast majority of us do not have a home in Palm Springs, or even closer to home, in Nichols Hills. Guess what else; 4% of us never make it until our 25th birthday, almost 1% of us reside in prison, 10% of us do not have a cell phone. Sad but true.
          A campaign slogan of former president, Harry S. Truman, was “a chicken in every pot and a car in every garage”. That was almost 70 years ago. Nice slogan but we are nowhere near that even now and it just won’t happen anytime soon.
          Is any of the above really a role of the federal government? More importantly, is any of the above something any centralized government can fix? Think about that and think about that statement of any of this being a RIGHT, whether our Constitution, the Magna Carta or anything else, including the Bible.
          Whatever Congress and the President decide about a law instituting healthcare/ insurance will again head to the Supreme Court [SCOTUS], bet large on that. The makeup of this Court will be quite different than the last charade that ruled on the ACA. It is my understanding that the latest nominee is a Constitutional Originalist. I guess we are “fixin’ to find out”. If he is a said Originalist, whatever the role of Fed Gov remains at the federal level is in jeopardy, other than a pass through to the States, where it belongs.
          The role of SCOTUS is not to make a value judgement, as did the previous Court. The role of the Court is to determine the Constitutionality of a law and the Statutes pursuant thereto. They are to look at whether Art 1 Section 8, and laws pursuant, includes a federal role in healthcare, period. It does not, simply stated. Read it yourself and tell me the Fed Gov even has a dog in that hunt. But, you say, “We all have a RIGHT…”
          While we all here are born with the same equal opportunity, we all don’t end up with equal results. Ah yes, those prickly laws of nature… Where you end up is what you earn, not what the government provides. If your self-worth and self-reliance takes you to a lofty life style, I say well deserved. If it is however, based upon what you get from the government, you are simply a ward of the state and that just ain’t very lofty. If you have an iPhone and a BMW and live in mommy’s basement and daddy paid for it all, you didn’t earn it, mommy and daddy did. Your self-actualization is determined by yourself, individually, by what you earn; not that of mommy and daddy, not Fed Gov. YOU!

          For those of you who say that healthcare/ insurance should be a federal prerogative, there are two ways to amend the Constitution to get that done. The framers provided those mechanisms and that is why it is a “Living Document”; it can be expanded in time if it is determined a sufficient enough priority to include. It only takes ¾ of the States to agree to an amendment. Good luck Chuck! Please note that I said STATES—we are a Republic, not a free for all democracy as some would wish. Otherwise, it is just another Letter to Santa Wish List. It is not the role of the Fed Gov to make sure we all have a car, iPhone, live to collect Social Security, a home in Palm Springs or even healthcare/ insurance, dread the thought. “If wishes were fishes…” Where/ when did we come up with thinking we deserve all of this crap or that it is a RIGHT? Ultimately, you will get what you paid for and you will get paid for what you earn. THAT is a veritable right.